Best Nursing Homes Insurance Companies
Choosing the right insurance carrier for nursing homes matters as much as the coverage itself. We compare the top carriers writing nursing homes insurance based on financial strength, claims service, industry expertise, and pricing.
Get a Quote →Which Nursing Homes Insurance Companies Rank Highest?
Choosing the right insurance carrier for your nursing homes business requires looking beyond premium price. Classified under NCCI 8829 (Nursing homes — all employees including nurses, aides, and support staff) (WC) and ISO GL class code 80712 (Nursing home facilities) (GL), nursing homes need carriers that actively underwrite these classifications with competitive rates and industry-specific expertise. (Source: NCCI, ISO)
Nursing care facilities have the highest nonfatal injury rate of any industry at 8.1 per 100 FTE — nearly 3× the all-industry average. Patient handling injuries account for 48% of all claims (Source: BLS SOII, 2022) Carriers with dedicated nursing homes underwriting teams use this loss data to write better coverage at more competitive premiums than generalists.
Who Are the Top 5 Recommended Carriers for Nursing Homes?
1. Berkshire Hathaway (BHSI) (A++ (Superior)) — Healthcare risks with the strongest balance sheet in insurance. Occurrence-based PL forms with long-tail protection. AM Best FSC XV. NAIC complaint index 0.82.
2. Medical Protective (A++ (Superior)) — Berkshire Hathaway company — one of the oldest medical malpractice carriers in the U.S. Consent-to-settle clause gives physicians control. Defense network in every state. AM Best FSC XV.
3. CNA Healthcare (A (Excellent)) — One of the largest healthcare PL books in the U.S. Covers hospitals, nursing homes, ALFs, and practitioners. Risk management resources include patient safety protocols. AM Best FSC XV. NAIC complaint index 0.92.
Selection note: These carriers were selected based on AM Best financial strength (A- minimum), NAIC complaint index, demonstrated appetite for nursing homes classifications (NCCI 8829 (Nursing homes — all employees including nurses, aides, and support staff), ISO GL class code 80712 (Nursing home facilities)), and claims handling reputation in your industry.
4. The Doctors Company (A (Excellent)) — Physician-owned medical malpractice carrier — the largest in the U.S. Their governance structure means policyholder interests drive coverage decisions, not shareholder returns. AM Best FSC XIV.
5. NORCAL Group (A (Excellent)) — Part of ProAssurance. Physician-focused medical PL with risk management CME programs. Strong presence in western states. AM Best FSC XII.
What Nursing Homes Should Expect from Their Insurance Carrier
Beyond competitive pricing, the right carrier for nursing homes should deliver:
Responsive claims handling: When nursing homes file claims, specialist carriers assign adjusters who understand your industry. This means faster resolution, less business disruption, and more favorable outcomes.
Stable renewal pricing: Specialist carriers commit to nursing homes as a core market — they don’t spike renewal premiums when market conditions tighten. Look for carriers with 3+ year renewal history with similar accounts.
Proactive risk management: The best carriers don’t just pay claims — they help prevent them. Loss control engineers, safety training resources, and claims trend analysis are value-adds that reduce your total cost of risk.
Contract compliance support: nursing homes contracts increasingly require specific endorsements, additional insured forms, and waiver language. Your carrier should support these requirements without delays or additional charges.
How We Evaluate Insurance Carriers for Nursing Homes
Our carrier recommendations for nursing homes are based on four objective data points:
1. AM Best Financial Strength Rating — measures the carrier’s ability to pay claims. We require A- (Excellent) or better for all nursing homes recommendations. Ratings are published at ambest.com. (Source: AM Best Rating Services)
2. AM Best Financial Size Category (FSC) — indicates policyholder surplus. For nursing homes, carriers with FSC X ($500M+) or greater provide the capacity needed for adequate limit structures.
3. NAIC Complaint Index — compares complaints to premium volume. An index below 1.0 means fewer complaints than the industry median. We target carriers below 0.90 for nursing homes. (Source: NAIC Consumer Information Source, content.naic.org)
4. Industry Specialization — carriers with dedicated nursing homes underwriting teams write broader coverage, handle claims faster, and provide more stable renewal pricing than generalists.
How to verify: Search any carrier at the NAIC Consumer Information Source (content.naic.org) for complaint history and at AM Best (ambest.com) for financial strength. Your state Department of Insurance website publishes state-specific carrier data.
How Does Industry Risk Affect Nursing Homes Carrier Selection?
The insurance carriers that perform best for nursing homes are those with deep experience in your industry’s specific risk profile:
Nursing care facilities have the highest nonfatal injury rate of any industry at 8.1 per 100 FTE — nearly 3× the all-industry average. Patient handling injuries account for 48% of all claims (Source: BLS SOII, 2022) Patient lifting and repositioning (the leading cause at 48% of claims), slip-and-fall on wet surfaces, workplace violence from residents with cognitive impairment, and needlestick/sharps injuries. Average claim severity: Average nursing home WC lost-time claim: $38,400 — the highest average in healthcare.
Carriers with this data in their actuarial models price nursing homes accounts more accurately than carriers guessing based on broad industry categories. Accurate pricing means competitive premiums and stable renewals — not first-year discounts followed by steep increases when the carrier realizes the risk was mispriced.
Regulatory context: OSHA safe patient handling and mobility guidelines, CMS Nursing Home Conditions of Participation (42 CFR 483), state nursing home licensing and staffing ratio requirements, and 29 CFR 1910.1030 (Bloodborne Pathogens). Carriers that understand these standards evaluate your compliance as a positive underwriting factor — giving you credit for what generalists overlook.
Where Can Nursing Homes Find More Insurance Resources?
- Learn About Nursing Homes Insurance
- Cost of Nursing Homes Insurance
- Nursing Homes Compliance Guide
- Nursing Homes Certificate Requirements
- Workers Compensation for Nursing Homes Insurance
- Learn About Umbrella / Excess Liability for Nursing Homes
- Learn About Surety Bonds for Nursing Homes
Compare Nursing Homes Insurance Carriers Free
Coverage Axis compares carriers like Berkshire Hathaway (BHSI), CNA Healthcare, and NORCAL Group side by side for your specific nursing homes operation. We evaluate coverage terms, claims reputation, and premium — then present your options in a single comparison. Free, no obligation. Start your carrier comparison today.
Get Nursing Homes Insurance Quote
50+ carriers. One advisor. One recommendation built around your business — no obligation.
Get My Free Review →TOP CARRIERS
Best Insurance Companies
Berkshire Hathaway (BHSI)
Healthcare risks with the strongest balance sheet in insurance. Occurrence-based PL forms with long-tail protection. AM Best FSC XV. NAIC complaint index 0.82.
Medical Protective
Berkshire Hathaway company — one of the oldest medical malpractice carriers in the U.S. Consent-to-settle clause gives physicians control. Defense network in every state. AM Best FSC XV.
CNA Healthcare
One of the largest healthcare PL books in the U.S. Covers hospitals, nursing homes, ALFs, and practitioners. Risk management resources include patient safety protocols. AM Best FSC XV. NAIC complaint index 0.92.
The Doctors Company
Physician-owned medical malpractice carrier — the largest in the U.S. Their governance structure means policyholder interests drive coverage decisions, not shareholder returns. AM Best FSC XIV.
NORCAL Group
Part of ProAssurance. Physician-focused medical PL with risk management CME programs. Strong presence in western states. AM Best FSC XII.
HOW TO CHOOSE
Selection Criteria
Risk Management Resources
The best healthcare carriers provide patient safety consulting, continuing education credits, and clinical risk management tools. These resources reduce claim frequency and demonstrate to underwriters that your organization prioritizes patient safety.
Cyber Liability with HIPAA Response
Healthcare data breaches trigger HIPAA notification requirements and potential HHS penalties. Carriers offering cyber liability with built-in breach response — including forensic investigation, patient notification, and credit monitoring — simplify incident response when a breach occurs.
Occurrence vs. Claims-Made Forms
Occurrence-based professional liability covers incidents that happen during the policy period regardless of when the claim is reported. Claims-made forms are cheaper initially but require tail coverage at retirement. Healthcare businesses should evaluate total cost of ownership, not just first-year premium.
Regulatory Defense Coverage
Healthcare businesses face regulatory actions from state licensing boards, CMS, and HHS. Carriers offering regulatory defense coverage pay legal costs for license defense, Medicare/Medicaid audits, and HIPAA enforcement actions.
Consent-to-Settle Provisions
For physicians and surgeons, a malpractice settlement can trigger National Practitioner Data Bank reporting. Carriers with consent-to-settle clauses give practitioners control over whether a case settles or goes to trial, protecting their professional reputation.
COVERAGE COSTS
What does each coverage cost for Nursing Homes?
Dollar ranges for every coverage type, with the underwriting drivers that move premium up or down.
WHY COVERAGE AXIS
Why Coverage Axis
Insurance Carriers
Access to a broad network of A-rated carriers competing for your business — your advisor handles the rest.
COI Turnaround
Certificates and additional insured endorsements delivered the same day you need them.
Years of Experience
Our advisors specialize in commercial insurance — we understand your industry inside and out.
Cost to You
Getting a quote is always free. No hidden fees, no obligation — just straightforward coverage advice.
YOUR ADVISOR
Chris DeCarolis
Senior Commercial Insurance Advisor
Chris DeCarolis is a Senior Commercial Insurance Advisor at Coverage Axis. His experience in commercial risk placement started in 2007. He has helped contractors, trades, and specialty businesses build coverage programs that fit their operations — specializing in general liability, workers comp, commercial auto, and umbrella programs for high-risk industries. Chris holds a Florida 220 General Lines license (G038859) and is a graduate of Brown University.
COMMON QUESTIONS
Frequently Asked Questions
The top carriers for nursing homes include Medical Protective and other A-rated companies with dedicated underwriting teams for your industry. The best carrier for your specific operation depends on your risk profile, coverage needs, and claims history — Coverage Axis compares 50+ carriers to find your best match.
Focus on carrier expertise in your specific industry rather than just premium price. Key evaluation criteria include Risk Management Resources, AM Best financial strength rating, claims handling reputation, and willingness to provide long-term pricing stability. An independent advisor like Coverage Axis can evaluate these factors across multiple carriers simultaneously.
Yes. AM Best ratings reflect a carrier's financial ability to pay claims. We recommend carriers rated A- (Excellent) or better for nursing homes coverage. However, AM Best rating alone is not sufficient — a financially strong carrier with no industry expertise may offer inferior coverage terms compared to a specialist with the same rating.
Most nursing homes benefit from a primary carrier relationship for core coverage lines (GL, WC, auto) and may add specialty carriers for specific exposures. Bundling core lines with one carrier often earns package discounts of 10-15%. Coverage Axis designs multi-carrier programs when a single carrier cannot adequately cover all your exposures.
We recommend marketing your account to multiple carriers at least every 2-3 years, or immediately after a significant rate increase. Carrier pricing and appetite change constantly — a carrier that was uncompetitive last year may offer the best terms today. Coverage Axis handles the marketing process so you get competitive options without the legwork.
GET STARTED
Compare Nursing Homes Insurance Carriers
Get quotes from the best carriers for nursing homes.
Get My Free Review →GET STARTED
Tell Us About Your Business
Fill out the form below and a licensed advisor will review your situation and recommend the right coverage — no obligation.